Be sure to read our Shipping Policies before you place an order!
Because of warm temperatures and shipping times, from May to September we only ship to these states:
Connecticut, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota, New York, North Carolina,
Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia, and Wisconsin.

We reserve the right to cancel and refund any order if we
deem the temperature too warm to ship safely.

We require a minimum order of $20 (before shipping).
Free shipping on orders over $150.00!*

The cheeses in the Traditional, Organic, Grass-fed, and Goat categories are produced in the heart of Ohio Amish country by one of the last farmer-owned dairy co-ops in the US. The milk comes from the farms of Amish families who generally keep 10–20 cows and refrain from using hormones and prophylactic antibiotics on their herds. The milk is delivered fresh daily, where it is transformed into delicious natural cheeses by traditional cheese-making methods, yielding a natural, high-quality product. The Amish cheese is moist, pungent, and flavorful. The cheese is pulled directly from the aging house and hand-cut just before your order is shipped. You will not likely find cheese like this at a more family-friendly price.

Featured Products


Farmers Cheese is delightfully basic and uncomplicated. It is a fresh, mild cheese with a slightly tangy taste, and a texture that is moist, yet dry enough to be sliced.

$3.50 - $29.00
Marble Pepper Jack

Marble Pepper Jack Cheese blends Monterey Jack with Colby and adds the spicy "zing" of jalapeño peppers to create a flavor that both comforts and invigorates.

$3.50 - $29.00
Pepper Jack

Pepper Jack Cheese is Monterey Jack cheese with the spicy "zing" of jalapeño peppers to create a flavor that both comforts and invigorates.

$3.50 - $29.00

Asiago is an aged cow's milk cheese that has a crumbly texture with a flavor reminiscent of Parmesan. This wonderful cheese is often grated in salads, soups, pastas, and sauces.

$3.80 - $33.00
Monterey Jack

Monterey Jack has no added color and has a smooth, understated yet distinctive flavor that makes it perfect as a topping to virtually any dish.

$3.50 - $29.00
Pearl Valley Amish Country Butter 2lbs

This hand-rolled delicious, salted butter is some of the best butter you've ever tasted. Perfect on bread, in cooking, and for eating by the slice.

Not quite as tasty as the salted variety, the unsalted butter is perfect for baking or for those who need less salt in their diet.

NOTE: We will not ship butter to southern locations during the summer months. If you order it, and we feel it is too warm, your money will be refunded.

Fresh Cheese Curds

Cheese Curds are squeaky fresh, delectable cheddar cheese in its natural, random shape and form before being processed into blocks of cheddar. Their flavor is mild with about the same firmness as cheese, but they have a slight rubbery texture

$3.50 - $225.00
Colby Longhorn

Similar in flavor to Cheddar, Colby Cheese is a stirred-curd cheese made with pasteurized milk, like Monterey Jack. Colby cheese has a slightly higher moisture content than cheddar, giving it a softer texture and a mellow, buttery flavor.

$3.50 - $29.00